Introduction

Financial consolidation is a critical process for companies with multiple subsidiaries or business units, as it combines financial data from various entities into a single, unified report. This process is essential for providing stakeholders with a clear picture of the organization’s overall financial health. However, when subsidiaries operate under different fiscal year starts, the consolidation process becomes significantly more complex. This blog explores the challenges of consolidating financial data across entities with varying fiscal year-ends, the concerns it raises, and how companies can address these issues effectively.

---

The Concerns of Different Fiscal Year Starts

When subsidiaries or business units have different fiscal year starts, financial consolidation becomes a logistical and technical challenge. Here are the primary concerns:

1. Misaligned Reporting Periods:
   Different fiscal year-ends mean that financial data from subsidiaries may not align with the parent company’s reporting period. This misalignment can lead to inconsistencies in revenue recognition, expense allocation, and overall financial performance analysis.
2. Data Accuracy and Comparability:
   Consolidating data from non-aligned periods can result in inaccuracies, as financial performance may not be directly comparable. For example, seasonal fluctuations in one subsidiary’s revenue might skew the consolidated results if not properly adjusted.
3. Increased Complexity in Adjustments:
   Companies must make manual adjustments to align financial data, such as pro-rating revenues or expenses, which can be time-consuming and prone to errors.
4. Regulatory and Compliance Risks:
   Many jurisdictions require consolidated financial statements to adhere to specific reporting standards. Misaligned fiscal years can complicate compliance with these regulations, increasing the risk of penalties or audits.
5. Resource Intensive:
   The process of consolidating data from different fiscal periods often requires additional resources, including specialized software, skilled personnel, and extended timelines.

---

Example: Consolidating a Global Retail Company

Consider a global retail company with subsidiaries in the US, Europe, and Asia. The parent company’s fiscal year runs from January to December, while the US subsidiary operates on a fiscal year from July to June, the European subsidiary from April to March, and the Asian subsidiary from October to September.

To consolidate financial data, the parent company must adjust the subsidiaries’ financial statements to align with its fiscal year. Here’s a more detailed breakdown of the adjustments, including the journal entries and accounts involved:

Step 1: Adjusting Revenue and Expenses (Partial Year)

As previously described, the parent company pro-rates the revenue and expenses of each subsidiary to align with its fiscal year. For example:

• US Subsidiary:
  • Revenue for January to December = 6million(pro−ratedfrom6million(pro–rated from 12 million).
  • Expenses for January to December = 4million(pro−ratedfrom4million(pro–rated from 8 million).
• European Subsidiary:
  • Revenue for January to December = 7.5million(pro−ratedfrom7.5million(pro–rated from 10 million).
  • Expenses for January to December = 4.5million(pro−ratedfrom4.5million(pro–rated from 6 million).
• Asian Subsidiary:
  • Revenue for January to December = 6.75million(pro−ratedfrom6.75million(pro–rated from 9 million).
  • Expenses for January to December = 3.75million(pro−ratedfrom3.75million(pro–rated from 5 million).

These adjustments ensure that only the revenue and expenses attributable to the parent company’s fiscal year are included in the consolidated financial statements.

Step 2: Adjusting Retained Earnings

Retained earnings represent the cumulative net income of a subsidiary that has not been distributed as dividends. When consolidating financial statements, the parent company must adjust the retained earnings of each subsidiary to account for:

1. The impact of prior-year adjustments (if any).
2. The portion of the subsidiary’s current-year net income that falls outside the parent company’s fiscal year.

Let’s assume the following for the US subsidiary:

• The US subsidiary’s retained earnings at the start of its fiscal year (July 1) were $20 million.
• Its net income for the fiscal year (July to June) is 4million (12 million revenue – $8 million expenses).

To adjust retained earnings:

1. Calculate the portion of net income attributable to the parent company’s fiscal year:
   • Net income for January to December = (4million/12months)×6months = 2 million.
2. Adjust the retained earnings:
   • The retained earnings at the start of the parent company’s fiscal year (January 1) would include:
     • The subsidiary’s retained earnings at July 1 ($20 million).
     • The net income earned from July to December ($2 million).
   • Therefore, the adjusted retained earnings at January 1 = $22 million.

Journal Entry:

• Debit: Retained Earnings (Subsidiary) – $22 million
• Credit: Retained Earnings (Parent Company) – $22 million

This entry ensures that the parent company’s consolidated retained earnings reflect the cumulative earnings of the subsidiary up to the start of its fiscal year.

Step 3: Consolidating the Financial Statements

After adjusting revenue, expenses, and retained earnings, the parent company consolidates the financial statements. The consolidated retained earnings will include:

1. The parent company’s retained earnings.
2. The adjusted retained earnings of each subsidiary.
3. The net income attributable to the parent company’s fiscal year.

For example:

• Parent company’s retained earnings: $50 million.
• Adjusted retained earnings of subsidiaries:
  • US subsidiary: $22 million.
  • European subsidiary: $18 million.
  • Asian subsidiary: $15 million.
• Consolidated retained earnings = 50million +22 million + 18million +15 million = $105 million.

---

Conclusion

When consolidating financial statements for companies with different fiscal year starts, it’s essential to adjust not only revenue and expenses but also retained earnings. Retained earnings adjustments ensure that the cumulative net income of subsidiaries is accurately reflected in the parent company’s consolidated financial statements.

By pro-rating revenue and expenses and adjusting retained earnings, companies can align financial data across subsidiaries, maintain compliance with accounting standards, and provide stakeholders with a clear and accurate picture of the organization’s financial performance. Advanced consolidation software can streamline this process, but a solid understanding of the underlying principles is crucial for finance teams to ensure accuracy and transparency.

This approach ensures that the consolidated financial statements are not only compliant but also meaningful for decision-making and stakeholder reporting.